Usenko wrote: ↑Tue, 19. Feb 19, 12:39
I'm afraid I'm with you, Bishop. When I first saw the article, my immediate question was "Which of the technical problems have they solved?"
The answer being "None of them. . . ."
^--- This.
This "announcement" is complete horsecrap... First of all, the "microwave solution" to power transmission has already been studied. It can't be done. Not with microwaves, it can't, using any form of technology currently known to mankind. So, yeah, that's right out as one may as well try to get heat from a candle to a cold cup of coffee by locking that candle in a refrigerator.
And, a LAZOR? Look... I know a laser and a microwave transmitter aren't the same thing. But, they're the same thing... just different. The atmospheric effects on a laser beam are WELL FRIGGIN' KNOWN. They are used in every darn half-decent observatory to calculate atmospheric effects so that the telescope can be adjusted. They are used to range distance to the Moon. Idiots use them to blind commercial pilots... The uses and capabilities are known variables up to the point where someone gets stoopid and say's "It's gonna be so stronk it can transmit huge amounts of collected energy."
That's not power-transmission.
That's a weapon.
The technical hurdles of mounting a laser in space capable of transmitting enough power to render usable energy "on the ground" are the same technical problems of creating space-based laser weapons platforms... And, we know that. China knows we know that. Everybody who's thinking about putting any sort of weapon's delivery system in space without having to pay for and hide the act of hauling up projectiles knows that.
All this talk of "collecting energy and beaming it down to Earth" is B.S. It'd be much simpler, cheaper, and more efficient to just cover a suitable area of land at the equator with extremely efficient solar panels and a closed steam system. Or, maybe, just build some of the great nuclear reactor systems that are out there to solve any "energy" problem.
It's friggin' B.S. It's dumb. It's propaganda that isn't intent on solving any dumbcrap "energy" issue, but is specifically designed to threaten "We're gonna build a space-based weapons platform and call it "clean energy," lol." Prepare for 100 bajigawatts of "clean energy to the face, lol."
:/
Added: This crap gets me mad... Seriously. This is about implying that China is threatening to violate the Space Treaty by cloaking a laser-based weapons platform in space by calling it an "energy transmitter." It won't happen, of course. But, it's the implied threat that is what they are trying to communicate. It's just a nudge, designed to inflame tensions. IF they actually started trying to do this? If they launched systems into orbit that were specifically designed to support this effort? It'd be grounds for a tactical strike to destroy such systems. This is much, much, more than what the US "Star Wars" program was designed for. This proposed "energy transmission system" is designed to kill people and break things on the ground anywhere on Earth from the relative (in today's terms) safety of space.
They're talking about building the Death Star.