Technology overtaking ficitonal SciFi technology: (update the fiction?)

Anything not relating to the X-Universe games (general tech talk, other games...) belongs here. Please read the rules before posting.

Moderator: Moderators for English X Forum

brucewarren
Posts: 9243
Joined: Wed, 26. Mar 08, 14:15
x3tc

Post by brucewarren » Sat, 8. Jul 17, 17:50

For me that idea doesn't work at all.

The whole idea of transferring consciousness is a very silly one. I know it's popular in some circles but it suffers from the same logical flaw that matter transporters do.

You're not transferring anything. What you're doing is creating a clone, and killing the original. For a computer program that's not a problem. For a real person it matters a great deal.

I can't speak for everyone but for me the idea that while I'm languishing in the fiery pits of Hell, or facing the prospect of non existence a copy of me is living what ought to be my life is of little comfort.

It also doesn't work because in Star Trek lore, holograms are not instances of people. They are computer programs. The real Zimmerman is very much still alive. If holograms were people then every time someone said "End program" he'd be committing murder.

birdtable
Posts: 2055
Joined: Sat, 7. Feb 04, 20:42
x4

Post by birdtable » Sat, 8. Jul 17, 18:50

"End program" could also mean .... sleep until required.
I see little difference from a computer to a brain,,, storage is neurons (human) and transmitted through the switching between the neurons ... just like reading a hard drive and allowing the cpu to produce the desired results .... only difference is the level complexity....
If you can transfer the required data in a computer you should be able to do the same with humans given the required research ....
Unless you believe that consciousness is stored nowhere to be called upon when required by magic then in time transfer would be possible .....
We are all just biological computers of very little significance that have evolved over thousands of years... nothing more.

brucewarren
Posts: 9243
Joined: Wed, 26. Mar 08, 14:15
x3tc

Post by brucewarren » Sat, 8. Jul 17, 19:12

The problem here is the word transfer. It makes it sound as if computer data is physically moved from a to b like bricks in a wheelbarrow. That almost never happens with computer data.You make a copy and then delete the original.

Even if you could make a computer with all the facilities of the brain and copy every last memory across with 100% accuracy you've still only made a copy of the person. You haven't transferred anything. You've made a copy.

So now you have two people. The one is an exact copy of the other. He may believe himself to be the other, but the original might have something to say on the matter. Do you then kill the original? He might have something to say about that too.

I recommend a video by CGP Grey called The trouble with transporters.

Sometimes an author will throw the magic word quantum into the mix as a form of handwavium. I for one no almost nothing about quantum mechanics and it's a reasonable assumption that most members of the public equally ignorant on the matter too.

Mightysword
Posts: 4350
Joined: Wed, 10. Mar 04, 05:11
x3tc

Post by Mightysword » Sat, 8. Jul 17, 19:18

brucewarren wrote: You're not transferring anything. What you're doing is creating a clone, and killing the original. For a computer program that's not a problem. For a real person it matters a great deal.

I can't speak for everyone but for me the idea that while I'm languishing in the fiery pits of Hell, or facing the prospect of non existence a copy of me is living what ought to be my life is of little comfort.
It kinda work in the setting of the anime though, granted I used the word transferring consciousness at my liberty so it may not have been a good choice of words. The idea of the anime wasn't to preserve the life of individual, but to maintain the existence of humanity.

So Yuki and his friends are about to die to the decease, their whole being are converted into data, then he died, that's it for the "real" Yuki, no one care about him anymore (because in the anime literally every single last human died, human essentially instinct). The super computer than using such data to emulate a word for the virtual Yuki and his friend to live in. Since the data is so accurate, the virtual Yuki will live exactly the way the real Yuki would. And not just him, but he will live along side his friends, his family, and the people of his city inside the virtual world. The idea is that one day when the condition allowed, an automatic facility based on the moon will start cloning these cluster of virtual population into physical being and imprint all of the data to that clone. A new Yuki will be born into the world with all the memory and experience of the old and virtual Yuki, thus maintain the continuation of humanity.

And as we know, human is actually a super computer and our memory bank far exceed any computer storage device, thus it's impossible for the computer to store/transfer a secondary of such a person.

brucewarren
Posts: 9243
Joined: Wed, 26. Mar 08, 14:15
x3tc

Post by brucewarren » Sat, 8. Jul 17, 19:34

Fair enough. I have to admit to an ignorance of anime too.

Pity we can't have multiple instances of the Doc though. Imagine how much more work he could do if there were dozens of him on the go. If there was a disaster and dozens of critically injured crew he could treat all of them at the same time.

Come on Starfleet we want multiple EMHs on our ships. Tell those lazy engineers back at HQ to get on it.

User avatar
Santi
Moderator (DevNet)
Moderator (DevNet)
Posts: 4046
Joined: Tue, 13. Feb 07, 21:06
x4

Post by Santi » Sat, 8. Jul 17, 20:40

Altered Carbon by Richard Morgan is an entertaining novel that in part deals with human personalities being stored in implanted at birth cortical stacks, and the use of "sleeves", human bodies grown in a tank with no sensorial input till a stack is implanted in them.

I think a Sci-Fi series, spawning several books over many years should stick to the lore created in the first books. As Brucewarren pointed out with the Foundation series, the trilogy made afterwards simply does not click with the spirit of the original books nor with the setting of a decaying Empire.
A por ellos que son pocos y cobardes

UniTrader
Moderator (Script&Mod)
Moderator (Script&Mod)
Posts: 14571
Joined: Sun, 20. Nov 05, 22:45
x4

Post by UniTrader » Sat, 8. Jul 17, 21:07

i think the Gundam Metaverse has a nice Solution for this Problem:
Keep the central Elements/Topics* but put them into a new Setting for each new Iteration/Universe.
(basically you could say each iteration is a new Franchise, though really its not)

i cannt give any recommendations here because most Gundam Series are running for a Year total and have roughly 50 Episodes, so certainly no quick watch.



* recurring elements of Gundam:
=> War is Hell
=> a Mysterious Masked Man
=> Haro
=> really surprising/shocking Plot twists


EDIT: and because it was just mentoined in a Video i watched: Final Fantasy does this too and is probably better known to most here. ok, its not really Sci-Fi but as far as i know each FF Game has its own Universe (sequels/prequels of course excluded) and not much connection between those..
if not stated otherwise everything i post is licensed under WTFPL

Ich mache keine S&M-Auftragsarbeiten, aber wenn es fragen gibt wie man etwas umsetzen kann helfe ich gerne weiter ;)

I wont do Script&Mod Request work, but if there are questions how to do something i will GLaDly help ;)

birdtable
Posts: 2055
Joined: Sat, 7. Feb 04, 20:42
x4

Post by birdtable » Sat, 8. Jul 17, 21:57

Robert Heinlein's book ... I Will Fear No Evil .... would cause some debate with personality transference .... :)

User avatar
red assassin
Posts: 4613
Joined: Sun, 15. Feb 04, 15:11
x3

Post by red assassin » Sat, 8. Jul 17, 22:30

brucewarren wrote:Sometimes an author will throw the magic word quantum into the mix as a form of handwavium. I for one no almost nothing about quantum mechanics and it's a reasonable assumption that most members of the public equally ignorant on the matter too.
This is actually fairly reasonable as far as handwavium goes - quantum information doesn't follow the same rules as the classical kind, and in particular you can't just copy quantum information - but one thing you can do is "teleport" a quantum state around. That is to say, if you have some system A at one location, and an identical system B at another, it's possible to rig up a system which allows you to teleport the state of A to B. This has been demonstrated for real with systems up to the complexity of a few particles (single atoms, that sort of thing).

If we assume that the complete, exact quantum state of a person is linked to their continuity of consciousness, which seems relatively reasonable, then in principle you can construct an exact replica of that person, teleport their quantum state over to the new one, and now we've teleported a person without murdering them in the process. (The practical issue here, of course, is that the ~10^28 atoms in a person amounts to a rather more complicated system than is probably practical to do this to.) But this doesn't necessarily get you out of the broader ethical issues, as now you have to deal with a) what happens to the body that's left behind (it'll have its quantum state thoroughly buggered, but it'll still be intact and theoretically able to wake up as a new person) and b) what happens to whatever consciousness was present in the destination body before you trampled it with the transferred one. So you've avoided murdering the person you're actually trying to transfer at the cost of creating two new people and promptly murdering one of them. Teleportation: Still an ethical minefield.

(Of course, there's also the question of whether continuity of consciousness is really a thing, or just a convenient fiction our brains tell us so we don't start refusing to go to sleep...)
A still more glorious dawn awaits, not a sunrise, but a galaxy rise, a morning filled with 400 billion suns - the rising of the Milky Way

Mightysword
Posts: 4350
Joined: Wed, 10. Mar 04, 05:11
x3tc

Post by Mightysword » Sat, 8. Jul 17, 23:37

Hey, this make me feel wanting to watch Zegapain again :D

The nice thing is, as I was watching the show, the same question came up in the anime. When the new kid saw the (data) partner of a veteran dying due to combat damage, he poses the question that I guess pretty much every audience must be wondering: "we're a bunch of data right, so don't we have a backup somewhere to restore your partner?" and what I said in the previous 2 post basically the explanation the veteran gave the kid.

So instead of skirting the detail like Star Trek, you can say the writer of this show was being due diligent. :)

User avatar
Morkonan
Posts: 10113
Joined: Sun, 25. Sep 11, 04:33
x3tc

Post by Morkonan » Sun, 9. Jul 17, 05:50

In Hamilton's "Night's Dawn" series, there's a concept that revolves around people's personalities being uploaded/stored. One of the major societies revolves around beliefs that deal with uploaded/stored consciousness.

In that setting, most don't believe that these stored consciousnesses are actually the real people they represent. Not even the consciousnesses themselves are quite sure if they are... they. :) Some maintain they are truly what they represent as the almost immortal consciousnesses of the humans that were stored and some do not. It's a very strange belief system unique to that culture, though, and it's certainly a value-added part of the story. So, in that case, it's all good, no matter if it's slightly squirrelly or not. :)

BUT, more significantly than whether or not such a thing is possible is the drama that gets created by the newly introduced stakes involved with these... people. And, of course, the way Hamilton fiddles with this new fiddly-bit introduced in his story makes for very entertaining reading.

Post Reply

Return to “Off Topic English”